
In my quest for an electronic reading device, I picked up a
nook. It wasn't on my list of devices to try because it weighs
more than the
Sony PRS-700 I already nixed, but the deal on eBay was too good to resist - $210 Buy It Now,
including a $50 B&N gift certificate. And it's a good thing that certificate was included, as within days B&N dropped the price on the original nook to $199! Isn't that always the story with electronics...
My take on the nook after using it for just over a week:
Design:I enjoy the quality of the design - the rubber back, combined with the wide bezel, makes it easy on the eyes and easy to hold. It looks like a Mac product, with its minimal buttons and touchscreen. My only real complaint is the click noise the buttons make. It's unnoticeable most of the time, but in a quiet dark room, it is loud enough to disturb a dozing baby. Luckily the touchscreen is an available option for silent page turns. I prefer the buttons, because I have a better hold on the device, but swiping is quieter at night.
Touchscreen:It's not as responsive as the iPhone screen or MacBook Pro trackpad, that I'm used to -- but it is respectable. There is a noticeable pause, but not a true lag like I've seen with other devices. I'm looking at you, TomTom GPS! Typing with the touchscreen keyboard is more awkward than the iPhone, mostly because you're trying to balance a much larger device in one hand and tap with the other. My hands are too small to thumb-type.
Contrast:Wow! The contrast is remarkable on this screen. The background is much closer to white than other e-Ink screens I've seen, not the grey of a newspaper, which is what the Sony screens have looked like to me. Both letters and artwork appear very crisp -- I see now why there is such a groundswell of screen savers and wallpapers for the nook - they look great. And reading on an e-Ink is a joy, compared to the tiring on my iPhone. I'm hoping it will be the same once I add a light.
Lighting:There is no built-in lighting on this particular e-Ink device. I have purchased a
Lyra Light and I have also used a
M-Edge eLuminator2 sold for the Kindle, so I can read in the dark. Glare from the screen is moderate, but glare from the glossy bezel is noticeable, even annoying. This could be fixed by a case or a decal, so I'm not going to worry about it.
Speed:Page turns are a bit slower than the PRS-700. I have to push for next page at about the 3rd to last line in order to keep my reading rythym. That is supposed to be an improvement in 1.3, so I have to add that firmware and see. I added both the 1.3 and 1.4 foirmware and what a difference! The nook now has the fastest refresh of the 4 e-Ink devices I have tried.
Software:I would rate the nook software as average/mediocre. While it isn't awful in any way, it isn't very slick, either. Navigating the touchscreen on the bottom is a little counterintuitive. I still am never sure how the scroll bar works. And the arbitrary division between My Library and My Documents is ridiculous. I've been e-reading for 7 years, so I have a 200+ library of .PDB books bought from B&N subsidiaries, but they get dumped into a separate folder, with no organizing capabilities. All my meticulously tagged series are useless on the nook. Not too mention organizing public domain and library ePubs.
The reading software reads ePub and .pdb eReader DRM formats. The Light Classic font is attractive, but I personally find Helvetica Neue and Amasis to be awkward for reading book-length texts. I've found Light Classic Large to be the best size for me to read, although Amasis Medium is okay. Helvetica Neue is just awkward for book-length texts. I haven't tried the PDF option - the majority of my eBooks are in ePub or easily converted to ePub, so this is not of concern to me, although some library books come in PDF, so I should give that a try.
The desktop software is Barnes & Noble eReader, a re-branded version of the eReader software I already had. It works fine on my Mac. There is no "sync" option to keep your "reading now" spot between the desktop, nook or iPhone - that's a pretty nifty feature that seems to be specific to Amazon-purchased titles. (Update: Apple has added a similar feature to iBooks 1.1,
but it syncs all books not just iBooks-purchased.)
Ergonomics:It doesn't
feel heavier than the Sony PRS-700 (12.1 oz vs the PRs-700's 10.1 oz), even though it is both heavier and taller (although slightly slimmer). I think that is because of the way it is designed to be held by the middle, rather than the bottom. Weight is more evenly distributed. However, it is still noticeably heavier and bulkier to read on than my iPhone. :)
I really wish the top page-back buttons were the page forward buttons. Then I could use the nook one-handed more comfortably. It's less tiring than the PRS-700 was, but keeping the nook balanced in one hand starts to drag on my wrist and elbow after a bit, and it is harder to manage when laying down. I tried to hold it one-handed and use the thumb of that same hand to swipe the touchscreen to turn the page, but this was impossible with my small hands. I'm most comfortable holding it in two hands to hold it steady. For my daytime reading, the nook is a perfect device. For evening, it's not impossible, but more difficult than I'd prefer. There are several easel cases available that I am investigating before giving up on the nook.
I feel this problem could have been easily fixed by having page buttons be reversed, perhaps as a settings preference. There is a third-party fix, but it requires "soft-rooting."
Conclusion:I read in bed, I read in the car, I read at work briefly (the flourescents reflection in the nook's shiny bezel annoyed me), I read on the couch. All told, I think I have spent 35 hours reading on this device over a week. I want to like it. If I can find a solution to holding it in bed, I think I will.
So now, I'm evaluating my other eBay find: the Sony Pocket Edition. If it is more one-hand friendly, and has better organization software, then I'll have my new reader and the nook will need to find a new home.